Wednesday, December 13, 2023

Speaker Efficiency, Sensitivity and Impedance

 This comes up a lot so worth trying to distill closely related specifications together. 

Speaker efficiency and sensitivity are often treated as the same, but they are different.  Both measure output at 1 meter in decibels, the issue is the input.

Sensitivity:  Output at 2.83V at 1m.  In other words, output vs. VOLTAGE.

Efficiency:  Output at 1W at 1m.  In other words, output vs. POWER.

If you have an 8 ohm speaker, sensitivity and efficiency are equivalent, because 2.83V into 8 Ohms = 1 Watt. 

Here’s a common example: Many mid woofers come in 8 ohm and 4 ohm versions. Nearly identical in all other aspects besides the impedance curves. The 8 Ohm version produces 87 dB at 2.83 V. That is, 87 db @ 1 Watt. The 4 ohm speaker produces 90 dB @ 2.83V, but since it has 2x the current it is 90 dB @ 2 Watts.

We care much more about this difference when dealing with tube or modest output amplifiers. 

If you care about whether a speaker is difficult to drive though, consider the minimum impedance.  Anything below 3.5 Ohms will start to get difficult for most receivers. 

Wednesday, November 1, 2023

Buying and Living With Focal Speakers

Think of this as a no BS guide to getting the most out of a pair of Focal floor-standers. 

I have followed Focal speaker development closely since the introduction of the Utopias with the titanium tweeter and dual midrange units.  I've been listening to them,  looking at online measurements as well as doing my own speaker and crossover analysis from time to time when I was a Focal owner as well.  I hope that my experience can help you get the most from your Focals if that's how you've chosen to go.


The modern Focals, from the Kanta to the Utopia range share some common challenges in getting the bass/mid/treble balance right which a new Focal owner may not be aware of.  First we'll cover placement, and then amplifier selection. 

None of these suggestions are absolute, but some are counter-intuitive so experimenting with these suggestions may help you get to an ideal musical experience more quickly. 

Simple Rules 

Some rules you probably want to follow: 
  1. Close to a rear wall
  2. Far from side walls
  3. Minimal toe-in 
  4. Absorbers on the sides between listener and speaker, not just 1st reflection points. 
  5. Strong amplifier 

Focals usually benefit from being close to the rear and far from the sides compared to other speakers.  Definitely not a speaker that likes being isolated in the middle of the room. 

Audiophiles often use a laser level to point tweeters directly at their listening chair.  Don't do that. The metal dome's will sound smoother if you point them behind your head.  Also the imaging gets better.  When first set up you may hear a left and right, and strong center but lack of fill between the center and sides.  That's what the correct toe-in will help. 

 

Room Treatment

Another concern with Focals is how smoothly the frequency response falls off to the sides.  Too much here and you'll end up with a speaker that tonally sounds too bright.  See the red line below.   



The plot here is taken from Stereophile's Evo Utopia review, but is a common trait among focals from the Kantas on up due to the dispersion of the inverted dome.  The red line is a theoretically better curve.  Essentially there is too much off-axis energy from 5 kHz to 10 kHz compared to the range below and above.  The best way to deal with this is absorbers on the sides of the listening area to help drain that energy faster.  This effect is worse in some lines than the other but you should keep it in mind.  This will also greatly improve imaging and help the music appear to be wider than the speakers instead of only between them. 

Failure to take these items into consideration may make the speaker sound like it is lacking in the bass, despite the on-axis measurements.  

The top end Focals come with jumpers to adjust the relative driver levels and many of us have access to EQ via our equipment or streamers.  I strongly encourage you to start with the room treatment first, since the issue here isn't output, but the horizontal shape of the output.  Once that is in place you'll have a better time adjusting any levels. Alternatively, experiment with little to no toe-in and adjusting the levels appropriately.


Speaker Impedance

Another "signature" feature of Focals is having a very low impedance (3 Ohms or lower) around 100 Hz. In at least one crossover I examined this seems to have been a deliberate choice.  Regardless of why, you should be aware of this issue and know that light-weight receivers may not do the speaker justice.  From the same Stereophle review:


In the same review John Atkinson measures an equivalent resistance (EDPR) of under 2 Ohms. This is a punishing load, and typical for Focals.  These speakers require high current amps to perform most consistently at all volumes. Some reviewers will praise them for being able to show differences between different amplifiers but I will not. I would prefer they were easy to drive and allowed me to get excellent performance with a variety of tube and solid state amplifiers. 

Speaker Capacitors

I am not 100% sure but it seems to me Focal often uses Solen capacitors (rebranded as Focal) often in series with the tweeters and midrange units.  This may vary based on the level of the speaker.  In the cases of the Focal cap brand being used my experience is that even inexpensive Mundorf MKP caps can really remove a great deal of harshness with no loss of detail.  Definitely not something to do with your Evo Utopias but perhaps if you have older Focals and wish to undertake a little speaker modifications I would recommend this approach. 

Check all Woofers

Lightly touch all woofers to ensure they are playing.  The reason for this is that the inductors are wired very tightly to the circuit boards and the leads may crack during shipment.  If one out of four woofers stops playing you may not even know it happened.  An alternative method is to use a Dayton DATS to check the impedance of the speakers to make sure they match. 

Conclusion

The combination of placement, dispersion and impedance may add together to give the listener the impression of a speaker that is too forward or even bright.  Careful attention to the principles above will help you achieve a much more neutral experience and highlight their bass output.